Carlisle Bay

David Napier

Stayed in one of the newly renovated ocean view rooms. Fabulous. Staff were wonderful. Breakfasts outstanding. The Jetty and Indigo were on the most part excellent. East and Ottimo were disappointing. The staff in East not up to the same standard as elsewhere in the resort and the food pretty uninspiring apart from the dynamite shrimp. Ottimo had the most unusual chairs/ table set up which made eating uncomfortable. The food offering was average at best, and again service not on par with other areas of the resort. Housekeeping was inconsistent and apart from not having our room serviced one day (this was rectified on the same day/evening) I constantly had to request more shower gel and other toiletries. Most disappointing. Finally, the forensic checking of our bill at the end of the holiday. There appears to be a problem with the accounting system, keying of information as despite photographing each signed receipt spurious amounts appeared on my bill. Happy to say these were resolved eventually but this shouldn't be the case and taints the experience at the end of your holiday. Notwithstanding the above on reflection I hadl a fantastic stay and I would recommend this resort.

Chris T

We recently stayed at Carlisle Bay Resort in Antigua and had a mixed experience. The restaurant service was genuinely good - the staff were friendly, attentive, and a pleasure to interact with. Unfortunately, this was not reflected at the management level. Management appeared disengaged and unresponsive throughout our stay. If you’re considering booking through Amex Fine Hotels & Resorts, I wouldn’t recommend it. Promised upgrades were ignored despite availability being shown directly on the hotel’s website. Likewise, my Leading Hotels of the World Sterling status was completely overlooked. There was no pre-arrival communication or acknowledgement, despite this being confirmed in advance. For the price point, the rooms are disappointing. They feel outdated and are in clear need of refurbishment, which does not align with the luxury positioning of the resort. Overall, while the frontline restaurant staff were excellent, the lack of management attentiveness and unmet benefits significantly detracted from the experience.

Guy

We stayed for 6 days in this hotel in Antigua. We stayed at suite 12 - the suites are huge ! We will definitely come back; the rooms are huge , new , modern and clean. the staff are amazing , every each person is so kind to you and make you feel like home. The location is the best , with amazing private beach. Kids and family friendly- including nanny services, kids club with great activities for kids. Very good food and restaurants- especially the Asian restaurant. The staff is there for you also when we needed a doctor consultation for one of the kids , they take care same day and sending a taxi to pharmacy for the prescriptions, checking on it every day. Excellent service.

Phil Lawyer

We spent a week at Carlisle Bay Resort and was blown away by the beauty, service, and attention to detail. From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel like royalty—greeting us with chilled towels, tropical drinks, and warm smiles. The location is absolutely stunning. Nestled between lush green hills and a calm, turquoise bay, the resort feels private and peaceful. We stayed in a Bay Suite, which was perfect for a romantic escape—spacious, beautifully designed. Waking up to ocean views and sipping coffee on our terrace was a highlight of every day. Dining was exceptional across the board. Indigo on the Beach served fresh, flavorful dishes in a relaxed beachfront setting, while East was a more refined experience with standout Asian fusion flavors. We also loved Ottimo! for casual poolside lunches—especially the wood-fired pizzas. Service throughout the resort was impeccable. Everyone, from housekeeping to the concierge, went out of their way to ensure our stay was flawless. We also appreciated the thoughtful division between family and adult-only areas, which helped maintain a peaceful atmosphere. If I had to find a minor critique, it would be that some areas of the resort—like parts of the pool deck—could benefit from a little refresh. But that’s honestly nitpicking. The overall experience was world-class. I have been here 5 times … Would I return? Absolutely. Carlisle Bay is the perfect blend of relaxed luxury, natural beauty, and five-star service. Highly recommend for couples, families, or anyone looking to unwind in paradise.

Danny Hayward

Stayed here and at Bluewaters, and honestly, there’s not much in it—they both have their strengths. If the beach is what matters most, this one wins hands down. The location is incredible, right on a stunning stretch of sand that really makes the stay. That said, if you’re after charm and atmosphere, Bluewaters just edges it. This hotel has loads of potential, but it could do with some refurbishment. But the best bit? Afternoon tea served to you on the beach. It honestly doesn’t get much better. A real standout experience that sets this place apart.