The New Yorker A Wyndham Hotel

Tullio Cata

Where do I start with this? Room was very cold. Thermostat didn’t work well no extra blankets into the room. I had a “queen” bed and we couldn’t fit well in it. I had to sleep on the pull out chair luckily. I asked for an accessible room and got still an half tub in the bathroom and my disabled mother couldn’t get in or out to shower. No microwave or coffee maker in the room or even plastic silverware only plastic cups. Great position, great lobby but not worth it for all the money they ask. NOT WORTH IT

Tracy Bevan

The beds are very comfortable & the room we had which was two beds with city view, were pretty spacious. The hotel is in a great location, right next to Penn Station. The only thing I would have liked is lights in the wardrobes which are essentially a cupboard so couldn’t see inside at night & there’s no tea, coffee facilities or a fridge-well not in our room anyway. Overall a good four star hotel which was adequate without paying for a five star hotel when you don’t spend much time in the room anyway

Nate Drake

Location - Excellent. Right next to The Garden. Great subway accessibility. 10 min walk to Hudson Yards. Lovely Jubbly. And that’s where the positive vibes end I’m afraid. Read the reviews after I booked. Thought “oh dear” So I splashed out and upgraded the room. If my room was an upgrade, I don’t want to know what a standard room would have been like. Probably a sardine tin. First off, the bed, where the magic happens! Mate, we could barely get me and the Mrs on the bed yet alone perform any magic. It’s smaller than a double! I didn’t get the tape measure out but the other reviews ring true. The room is so small that you can’t even open up your suitcase on the floor. And I know what you’re thinking. All rooms in NYC are small. Nah I’m a regular visitor to NYC and they have never been this small. Pardon my crudeness, but I couldn’t even take a dump. Never have I been in a hotel bathroom where I can’t dump. A man needs to dump. Standard hotel bathroom expectations. You can’t dump with the door closed and wipe your… you get the idea. Water either stone cold or scolding. Place your bets. There was times during the cramped 3 nights where I wondered if the room was getting smaller or I was just getting bigger. We will never know. And the cards never worked. Usual excuse. “Don’t put them near any phones or cameras etc” You know things that everyone has glued to them in 2024. Staff were fine but hard work when you needed something. And it’s real expensive for what you’re getting. Bill was $1600 for 3 nights. For a suitcase sized room. Overall, great location. Hotel needs a major overall. Won’t stay here ever again. I’ve actually booked Hard Rock Hotel for next time. For the same price.

Michelle Corkum

The only good thing about staying here was the central location. But there was a lot of problems with this hotel: 1) walls are paper thin to the point where I could hear neighbors talking at a normal volume 2) rooms are really cold and thermostats don’t seem to work or work well 3) most problematic issue: my key would erase every time I left the room! It got to the point where I almost didn’t want to leave because of how much of annoyance it was to wait in line and get it reset every time. And no, I didn’t have it near my phone credit card or any metal detectors. Workers at the front desk couldn’t have seemed to cared less about how inconvenient this is to their customers

Katelyn Barbour

I booked this hotel for a Christmas stay with my boyfriend. The location itself is worth the price alone, which is why we booked. But I must say, upon arrival I was pleasantly surprised by the appearance and the kindness of the staff. Thank you to Lynn, who helped us check in. Without even asking, she set us up with an early check in and a better room. She was super quick and efficient and so helpful. The ambience and the staff make the great location even better!! Will definitely be staying again.