The New Yorker A Wyndham Hotel

Laura Attick

Overall had a really memorable experience. The location is absolutely perfect, right by Penn Station, which made getting around the city super easy. You’re basically in the heart of Manhattan, which is ideal whether you're sightseeing, shopping, or just exploring. The staff were all friendly and helpful, especially the doorman an Italian New Yorker straight out of a movie. As someone visiting from England, it felt a bit surreal in the best way possible. He added a really authentic, almost cinematic vibe to the experience! The hotel itself has loads of character and history, which is part of the charm. You can’t help but think about all the famous people who have stayed there over the years—it definitely adds to the cool factor. That said, the rooms are quite dated and could use a bit of TLC (some new furnishings and a refresh wouldn’t go amiss). They’re clean and functional, but don’t expect modern luxury. In short: amazing location, friendly staff, and a unique, nostalgic atmosphere. If you're into history and classic NYC vibes, it's a great place to stay.

Rebecca Malek

Pretty great experience! I'm an NYC local who loves staying in hotels when the need arises. In this instance, I had a 2-day exam in the city and didn't want to risk the commute back on the train so I stayed here to be near to the exam center. Location is great for tourists who want to spend a lot of time in the theater district or even for folks who want to adventure out of Manhattan as Penn Station is right there, giving you easy access to basically the entire city and beyond. I've stayed in a lot of hotels in the city, and I would say this was one of the nicer rooms I've stayed in at the price point, but as a classic hotel, some of the things you would imagine -- slightly outdated fixtures, etc, definitely exist. But I think it's part of the charm. The room was clean and everyone was super nice. My literal only qualm was being awoken by the incredibly loud noise of what I believe was my next-door neighbor during their shower on and off, for whatever reason, it sounded like they were literally in my closet and it woke me up out of my sleep, which was not ideal since I had an enormous exam the next day. It might have been other pipe noises but either way very loud. So my one note would be to be aware that it may be a little loud in the hotel, but that's also just NYC in general. Overall would highly recommend.

Britt Hogg

We booked the standard Queen room with a view through Trivago deals. At checkin we were offered an upgrade to the Queen suite with a view on the 40th floor for $50 more a night. The deal that we got through Trivago was a great deal and the upgrade made it even better. We stayed in room 4004 with a view of lower Manhattan and it was worth the extra cost. There was minimal noise from the EMS and NYPD sirens passing by throughout the night that high up. Hotel security asks to see your room key before you can go to the elevators, which was a plus. The A,C,E, subway access is literally right out the door, there is a CVS, McDonalds and plenty of local paces to eat in the area. The Tick Tock dinner is a bit on the pricy side but the portion is quite large and sharable and the quality of food was very good. Time square is a short 18 minute walk and we never felt unsafe walking around day or night (wasn't out past midnight). The room was very clean, shower had great pressure, the hot water was immediate, there was a small fridge and K-cup coffee maker in the room, hair dryer along with plenty of towels in the bathroom, and the elevators and WiFi were fast. My wife and I loved the history of the property, the convenience of everything, the amazing staff! We will be staying here exclusively going forward when we travel to NYC.

Laura Acosta

I have never in my life been so delighted with a hotel stay! It was exceptional, and I felt compelled to leave a review because this was one of the most incredible trips of my life… and The New Yorker played a huge role in that. Prior to my trip, I had been in contact with John, Cris, and Yvonne in the Reservations department via email to help me make some last-minute changes to my itinerary, and they were beyond gracious and accommodating. I had booked what I thought was going to be a modest room at The New Yorker with convenient proximity to nearby attractions, but ended up with so much more than I expected! Gorgeous room with a magnificent balcony view of the NYC skyline… perfection! I am humbled, honored, and so incredibly grateful for the kindness and hospitality of the staff at The New Yorker. Highly recommend this place!

Daniela Barrera

The rooms are outdated but have everything you need and are spacious! The location is GREAT if you want to see lots of Broadway shows (very close to TS). My review is mainly for the service. The service at this hotel was absolutely fantastic! From the check in with Elijah (you were so sweet!!!) to the cleaning service everyday. The people that work at this hotel are what make it so great. A small renovation and this will be the best hotel in the city! Thanks for the great experience!!